Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We've gotten off track. I'm not arguing whether the market exists or how basic economics in a perfect market work.

If you look back at my original comment it's WRT the assertion that these landlords would love to upgrade their properties and charge higher rents. I was simply saying that's largely untrue. These landlords are aware of the market dynamics/demographic when choosing to invest and have little-to-no desire to "upgrade for higher margins".



They would have that desire if all their tenants were suddenly wealthy enough to pay those rents, was my point. Which speaks to the broader point that these landlords are not working to keep these people in poverty.


All of those tenants suddenly becoming wealthy enough to pay higher rents is a magical hypothetical that undermines the basis of this discussion. Someone else on this thread said it succinctly:

"If this market were wealthier it wouldn't exist"

That is exactly right.

The landlord would be more likely to wait for them to move elsewhere and just await more customers for their current offering as long as the market was there. This, rather than outlay the capital to upgrade the place; else the landlord would have likelier invested in a more upscale offering to begin with.

Likewise, depending on the degree of increased wealth, the tenants may well prefer to move. Slums and trailer parks generally don't have a tendency to just "happen" in otherwise affluent areas. With increased options, renters would likely desire better surroundings, schools, ownership, etc. vs new granite countertops in their double-wides.

Of course for this same reason, landlords don't want to risk upgrading beyond what can be recovered in a reasonable time by rents that the market will bear. No amount of upgrades is going to make more affluent buyers with other options move to a mobile park.

People are suggesting here that the landlord would upgrade because it's economically rational to collect higher rent, while simultaneously ignoring much of the actual economic reality here.

Again, I'm not claiming that the landlords create the market. But they are under no delusion when they invest.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: