Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You should learn more about a topic before posting.

It's very much like the EU: Each state is independent, and there is an overall governing body - the federal government, which for the most part can't tell states what to do, it can only give or withhold money to induce them.

There are specific rules about what the Federal government can and can't tell a state.

One difference that does exist is military, where EU states can have a military (as far I know), but US states can not.



> One difference that does exist is military, where EU states can have a military (as far I know), but US states can not.

Not so. US states cannot have a standing army without consent of Congress. The Congress has given such consent in the form of the Militia Act a century ago, which enabled the states to create the National Guard and the State Defense Forces / State Guard.

And while NG can be federalized (i.e. put under the federal chain of command, with the president as commander as chief), SDF are not - their chain of command terminates with the governor, and they cannot be used outside of state boundaries.

Most people in US know about the National Guard, but not about SDF. It's largely because the latter is rather small and obscure, and mostly used as a sort of civil defense agency with a military chain of command (many states don't even arm their units). But it's an interesting system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_defense_force


Note that the original Articles of Confederation included an explicit provision for State militias, that got replaced by the awkwardly worded 2nd Amendment in the Bill of Rights


Puzzles me, that nobody has mentioned this yet:

EU states are nation states, US states are not. The EU is not a nation, the US are.

EU states have much more sovereignty than US states written inside laws, but more importantly, through support of their people. This is why there is a Euro crisis and why Brexit happened: The unification of Europe is a beautiful idea and I personally hope it will recover, but while subsets of it were considered as one nation at some point (Austria, Germany etc.) the EU as a whole simply never was and never will be.


>It's very much like the EU

The EU, despite its name, is essentially a humongous cooperation deal between countries. It has many of the trappings of a nation, but that's an illusion. EU countries are sovereign (consent is required in any alteration of the membership rules and they can leave at will) but US states are not. That's the theory. In practice, the differences are even bigger: There's no EU patent system, for example.


Au contraire :)

I think the EU is becoming (and in some senses arguably already is) a quasi-state. Hence Brexit. That's kick back.

And there is now an EU-wide patent system: https://www.unified-patent-court.org/


When France goes to war it does so independently of the rest of the EU. And Britain has no obligation to help Sweden if Sweden is invaded. If that's not a hard line between nation-state and not, then I don't know what is.


The one big difference between an EU member nation and a state is that EU member nations can leave. A US state cannot secede, and so is ultimately under the control of the federal government.


> One difference that does exist is military, where EU states can have a military (as far I know), but US states can not

Even that is a little shaky, as historically there were organized state militias, which eventually evolved into the National Guard. Even now, the National Guard formations for each state are under the direct control of that state, rather than directly subordinated to the federal government.


If you admit uncertainty over whether EU states can have a military or not (yes obviously EU states can and do have their own military forces), perhaps you shouldn't lecture people on learning more before posting?


I do believe the US states can have a state militia and I believe some other form of national guard.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: