Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Clocks should be a means to measure time, not manipulate when people do things.


But think of the chaos if every person and business had to implement their own alternative to DST. Every business would change it's hours on a different date, and many wouldn't change their hours at all. Everyone would have to completely change their routines ad hocly. It's nice to have a single standard, and only have to change the clock.

If it helps, don't think of clock as a measure of the sun. Think of it as a measure of humanity's daily cycle. 12:00 is the middle of most people's day. Even if that isn't necessarily when the sun is highest in the sky. It's nice to have everyone's cycle regulated to a single standard.


Why would anyone want to implement their own DST? Why would anyone need to trick themselves by changing their clocks when they can just decide to get up at a different time?

And what was going on before DST was invented? Chaos?

And where people ignore this idea? Is it chaos there?


>Why would anyone want to implement their own DST? Why would anyone need to trick themselves by changing their clocks when they can just decide to get up at a different time?

That's what I mean. Imagine if business hours changed suddenly at a certain date instead of the clock itself changing. And every business had a different date, and some did change and some didn't, etc.

>And what was going on before DST was invented? Chaos? And where people ignore this idea? Is it chaos there?

To avoid the chaos, people didn't even try to do it. And they stayed on the same schedule year round. This means they lost an extra hour of sunlight for half the year. Which is a pretty undesirable outcome. Less time for outdoor activities, worse moods, increased depression, etc.


This is an argument against DST, not clocks.


That's right. I was referring to how clocks are used by DST to change our behavior. I wasn't arguing against clocks.


Unless you get up at 3AM, noon isn't the middle of your day.


It's the middle of your workday if you need daylight to work.


Yes, this! It's a measurement. Daylight savings time makes about as much sense to me as it would to have a "Winter Temperature Time", where we would all shift our thermometers up by some number of degrees to pretend it is still warm out. Nothing is actually changing, after all, we're just making it more difficult to talk about.


http://www.businessinsider.com/daylight-savings-dst-should-d...

"Daylight-saving time is dumb and we should get rid of it"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: