Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The FBI isn't a bunch of complete incompetents.

The FBI is human and therefor make mistakes, and they are a large organization and therefor have an structural inertia that occasionally directs a lot of power and effort at the wrong target.

Also, the price of democracy is eternal vigilance. Citizens have a duty to check the government's use of power. We should be worrying every time the government acts against a citizen until we also see proper due process including any necessary evidence.

> He could be found innocent

He is innocent until proven otherwise.

> what makes this case different

The government hasn't yet shown that they can handle this kind of case properly. That is partly due to the novel nature of situations involving new technology, but it is also from the government's own history of bad behavior. Their reputation means they do not get the benefit of the doubt, and until we see actual evidence that this case (regardless of the outcome) is being handled properly, it's prudent to worry that this might be an overreaching prosecutor (or worse).



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: