Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've just woken the wife up laughing. Is there some explanation of how this was constructed?


> We used predictive keyboards trained on all seven books to ghostwrite this spellbinding new Harry Potter chapter

https://twitter.com/botnikstudios/status/940627812259696643


The relative narrative coherence and the use of the term “predictive keyboards” instead of Markov-somethings has me fairly convinced this was actually just written by a human.

Still funny, though.


I think "used predictive keyboards" leaves enough wiggle room that there can be a human looking at the handful of suggestions and navigating through them, while letting the autosuggestions work their surreal magic. It seems a powerful combo to me. I love me a good Markov chain composition, but yeah, they really lack in the coherence department, which means they are whiffing on a level of good humor.

Edit: here's the tool: http://botnik.org/apps/writer/?source=d08198a9a936f791b7ffe1... My preliminary playing suggests there is definitely substantial human intervention. But the results are fun.


>while letting the autosuggestions work their surreal magic

I think that (unfortunately) gives way too much to the autosuggestions, and that the humans are doing the vast majority of the creative work.

My predictive keyboard on android offers 3 words, and if I try, I can delay the trap of falling into a loop and get a small amount of diversity in my sentences. If I had 18 words to work with, and they were specifically trained on the content of Harry Potter, that's a lot of room to exercise the kind of creativity that is still (for now) unique to humans.


How are predictive typing algorithms different from markov chains?


I believe the suggestion was that the keyboard offered up multiple options and a human chose from the available options.


The sentences were generated using predictive keyboards, and then the sentences were arranged into a story by a human editor, according to an article I read about it.


Whomever wrote this is quite the Racter


So basically extracted noun phrases and concatenated where the grammar fits?

I think I've seen it before somewhere.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: