Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

On an unrelated note, I wish there was an easy way to recommend typo fixes on blogs. I’ll often find them on my blogs too. He’s got one:

“One any fire is extinguished, e.g., by cutting off the fuel or blowing the”

Sometimes I’ll write a blog and not find my mistake for months. Linus’ Law applied to writing on the Internet.



For some blog sites I agree, but here it is Philip Greenspun who shares his email, phone number and physical mailing address on his website! I've sent an email about the typo at that address.

I usually look for an email on the blog site, then on thier other/main sites, then a direct message option on twitter, then a contact in whois for that domain, then, as much as it drive me nuts that it could be corrected so easily, it's just a tipo after all, and I try to let it go.


Hey, I was simply throwing out a suggestion that it would be nice to have a quick, quiet, and general way for everyone to deal with the problem.

If you like the current solution, and don’t see a problem, carry on.


I completely get you, and as someone who cringes at Linus Torvalds's "touch" typing style (which makes me wonder if that's where some of his overall "style" comes from), I wish there was an easy package or plugin that could be popularly applied to publishing and posting software (e.g., web browsers). It doesn't need to be mandatory, but I'm sure many people wouldn't mind the option so long as it's not open for abuse.


I've thought about this before too, especially with forums. Here, for example, there are lots of non-native speakers who make little mistakes that I would like to correct. But some people see that as rude or as being overly picky. But when I'm learning a foreign language I want people to point out my mistakes.

I like the way that StackOverflow does it where you can request edits. That way it doesn't waste other people's time or interfere with the conversation.


>But some people see that as rude or as being overly picky. But when I'm learning a foreign language I want people to point out my mistakes.

As a Dutchman and non-native speaker of English who learned most of it online I can tell you that I've always welcomed 'grammer nazis'. Especially before mobile phones made spellcheck a constant, online posts would engrave words in your brain with the wrong spelling.

I wished every board had a 'pull request' feature to privately let posters know about typos, like StackOverflow.

We still need to fix pronounciation though. When I was 14 I always thought Windows was telling me my copy was Genuine (Guh-nine) in stead of Genuine (Gen-you-in). But when do you ever hear that word on TV? Took me years before I stopped saying 'Guh-nine' in my head.

p.s. there is one in here for ya.


pronunciation - not pronounciation. :) (Is that what you meant by "there is one in here for ya"?)

But yes, I too have the universal "simple typo fixer" software idea on my Ideas list. Far too often, I come across atrocious spelling or grammar but don't want to fix it lest I be called out for being pedantic (or worse: not be called out and instead be silently scorned).

I'm not talking about writing beautiful prose (something I can't do), but just simple things such as usage of apostrophes. Apostrophe usage is probably the one that is most misunderstood for people who can otherwise write reasonably. [Never use an apostrophe unless it's for ownership or "is" - I think that's the best rule of thumb I can think of that will almost always work.]

People who write for a living also can be surprisingly regular offenders yet those are the ones who are often completely uncontactable (for obvious fair-enough reasons).


> pronunciation - not pronounciation. :) (Is that what you meant by "there is one in here for ya"?)

Yes! A difficult one for non-native speakers because of the seemingly arbitrary dropping of the 'o'. Pronounce -> pronunciation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: