Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I wholeheartedly agree. I wish one of the following three things would happen:

1. Apple notices the popularity of Hackintoshes (as well as certain long-time Mac users switching to Windows or Linux) and makes Macs that fit their needs in order to win these customers back.

2. Apple legitimizes the Hackintosh by selling licenses for PC use.

3. A competing operating system with a well-polished UI designed with time-tested UI practices and is built on a stable and secure foundation emerges for generic PCs. I have a dream of an operating system with a Mac OS 8/9 interface with a foundation that is highly influenced by Lisp machines, the Smalltalk environment, and Apple's OpenDoc component UI.



Apple have noticed high end users complaining, hence the iMac Pros and upcoming new Mac Pros.

Outside that, there is no perceptible loss of users. The much maligned Macbook Pros with butterfly keyboards and the touch bar are selling like there's no tomorrow.


> A competing operating system ... for generic PCs.

Never gonna happen. Mac's are very secure and polished exactly because there is no PCs and only Apple hardware. Think Secure Enclave and EFI. No freaking vendors and their requirements, done right because they can. Amen.


>Mac's are very secure and polished exactly because there is no PCs and only Apple hardware.

This seems obviously false, given the untold thousands of people running Hackintoshes (i.e., non-Apple hardware) with no reported security issues. I've run a Hackintosh for 5+ years and I've never had a problem with security. As for polish, my selected hardware is far better than what I could get from Apple, at 1/3 to 1/2 the cost of the nearest comparable (but still inferior) offerings from Apple.

I'm talking desktops. Laptops might be a different story. For desktops, Apple engineering has been lagging and just generally underwhelming for at least half a decade now, and I don't think they have the interest or even the ability (culture, etc.) to regain their hardware chops.


> false, given the untold thousands of people running Hackintoshes

ROFL :)) Had you read above? I'm running one myself. Your 'false' refers to what exactly? My statement was that there is no point for Apple to release MacOS for PCs. They will not be able to lock it down security wise.

BTW, how did you secure your hack from booting from install USB and resetting admin password on the main drive? Or from booting to Recovery partition and do stuff?

Asking, because you said you never had a problem with security, well, I Am the Problem, I will access your hack tomorrow :D

Cool, just got your home address ! www.youtube.com/watch?v=76wSk1j02_4


A good start might be to just implement the Platinum UI in Pharo and work from there.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: