Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thanks for all the responses.

My thoughts on a few of the points raised:

• Does meat cause cancer? I don't think so; I find the arguments unconvincing, and the rebuttals, convincing. In particular see:

- https://academic.oup.com/af/article/8/3/5/5048762

- http://peakhuman.libsyn.com/dr-david-klurfeld-on-meat-not-ca...

• Cow feed efficiency, clearing out forests, etc: Yeah, these forms of raising cattle are bad. I get my beef from here:

https://stemplecreek.com

The cows eat grass and live in harmony with their environment.

• Humane treatment: If you think killing an animal is inhumane, full stop, then sure, from that perspective, it is always inhumane to eat animals. I respect if you have that belief and are a vegetarian as a result.

But it's not a belief I hold.

Everything that lives is going to die; that's the game. The best we can hope for is to live well and to die well. We can give this to the animals we eat.

(I sometimes think of it like this: If all of Earth were some sort of human farm for aliens, would I want them to go vegetarian, replacing humans with vast fields of grain and synthetic labs growing human-like meat? No, I would not. I'd rather be a farm animal than not exist at all.)

• Demonstrate it works: Well, so far so good for me! I've tried eating vegan, vegetarian, the standard "well-balanced diet" (veggies, fruits, rice, potatoes, a little meat, a little fish), low-carb (veggies, meat), and now, pretty much just meat, with a little of fruit now and then. So far, the meat diet is _by far_ the most amazing for me.

I don't get sleepy after I eat, my stomach feels great, I'm getting stronger and leaner, and I'm still just as excited to eat a piece of meat as I was two months ago. We'll see how it works out with time!

I came to this way of eating because I was experiencing (1) frequent stomach aches (2) tiredness after eating (3) slowly but ever-increasing fatness. So I did a bunch of Googling around and looked at a bunch of accounts on twitter. The stuff I found the most compelling ended up being:

- https://twitter.com/tednaiman

- https://humanperformanceoutliers.libsyn.com

- http://peakhuman.libsyn.com

Check 'em out!



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: