Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No, it doesn’t.

There was a time period where people were trying to use/put services in Iceland or Switzerland because they weren’t part of a known default sharing arrangement and people completely relied on poor interpretations of laws acting like the government took a completely hands off approach to data. The reality is that absent a treaty, these places can all choose respond to foreign warrants and often times do.

China and Russia being notably separate from the rest of the world, and also large areas.



> The reality is that absent a treaty, these places can all choose respond to foreign warrants and often times do.

The question shouldn't be if they "can" the question should be if they "can be forced to and be legally required not to disclose it".

There is a reason American companies have tried to hack around the law with warrant canaries.


In your mind, how was the last paragraph relevant to the other country thing?

But the answer is yes they can be forced, absolutely. All countries have more to lose with the US (not that there is an ideological line in the sand, countries willingly cooperate with FBI, which is instructed by Congress to handle foreign investigations as well) and this is exactly what has played out in case after case after case.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: