No, it's nowhere near reasonable for her to do what she did. Everyone has a damn iPhone and they have very few models which all look very similar. The kid even had his own phone case which she asked him to remove. It's unreasonable to ask a stranger that just appeared in an elevator to give their phone to you.
And maybe it's a cultural thing but I've never seen a grown woman tackling a 14 year old kid to the ground like this, and if I ever do you can be sure I will call the police. Just because you've seen it often doesn't mean it should be normalised.
And no, she's not being "destroyed" by the racism accusation. But she might be destroyed if she goes to jail and gets a permanent record. And she had it coming. Actions HAVE consequences.
So I don't mean to say it's reasonable in normal circumstances, just given a little bit of hysteria after having lost an iPhone.
I guess I should have said 'undersandable' when someone is angry.
And yes - she is totally destroyed.
Do you understand the implications of your face being all over TMZ and CNN, publishing your name?
She will have death threats.
She will almost certainly lose her job if she has a normal job.
This will tar her for the rest of her life.
People commit suicide over this kind of stuff.
'Naming and shaming' for such a minor even is vindictive and terrible.
I understand CNN wanting to call attention to casual racism, but they should probably using these as 'lesson events' and probably not using real names.
They also dramatize by giving some back story 'son of a musician' and 'lady with a history of DUI' which is shameful - none of that is relevant.
Given how sensitive these things are they could be really polite about it, talk about what happened objective, talk about how the actors could have acted differently without names and colour commentary.
This is hyperbolic and disrespectful to people who actually went trough it.
Breaking the law has consequences. And the only consequence here is her being prosecuted for assault and battery and potentially going to jail. This has nothing to do with racism accusation, and is nothing compared to the torture you're suggesting.
And maybe it's a cultural thing but I've never seen a grown woman tackling a 14 year old kid to the ground like this, and if I ever do you can be sure I will call the police. Just because you've seen it often doesn't mean it should be normalised.
And no, she's not being "destroyed" by the racism accusation. But she might be destroyed if she goes to jail and gets a permanent record. And she had it coming. Actions HAVE consequences.