Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's really a pity that in 2021 I still have no out of the box program for playing MIDIs. With a vanilla Windows 95 installation, more then 20 years ago, I could just play a damned MIDI. Sure, the sound quality was shitty, but at least it allows me to get a first glance on the damned file.

Here on my "vanilla" arch linux installation, VLC won't play the MIDI. And https://www.pianojacq.com/ (recommended within this HN page) with Chromium won't either!



Why complain? If you desire to run Arch, then expect to read the wiki and pick up the configuration that the sloppy packagers won't provide.

https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/MIDI


Of course it's straightforward, install a few packages and you're done. I just was complaining about the poor adoption of MIDI. A standard linux distribution ships with a web browser, an image viewer, a music player, a PDF reader, but not a MIDI player. MIDI is just not very widespread, unfortunately.


Windows Media Player in Windows 10 still plays MIDI files. They've however removed the option to select a default MIDI device from the configuration GUI, so it'll always play on the built-in software wavetable synth unless you use a third party application to change the default.

For Linux, you can use aplaymidi from alsa-utils to play back on a MIDI port, or timidity for a software wavetable. I think most OS packaged versions of timidity ship with a basic soundfont so that you can listen straight away.

OS X, last I tried in maybe 2016 or 2015, had a built-in software synthesizer, and IIRC one of the built-in players used it for playback, maybe Quicktime.

I'd say support is pretty good considering how unlikely it seems that anyone should use SMAF as a consumption media format these days.


MIDI file playback support in macOS was removed in the 64-bit only transition in Catalina (since it relied on legacy QuickTime). If you opt to install Apple Garageband (free, preinstalled on new Macs I think) then that can play (and edit) them.

The OS still has a software synth and a high-level API for playing them, there's just no bundled app to interface with it.


Seconding sibling comment -- I'm running Ubuntu 20.10 and Timidity ran the MIDI file out of the box just fine.


What's wrong with Timidity exactly?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: