Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Perhaps it's not idle pedantry to observe that many of those who are angry about crypto energy usage couldn't care less about the energy wasted and pollution generated by other endeavors.

Have you observed this, or are you simply speculating?



Was thinking the same thing... There's no evidence I can see to suggest the parent is not also against other forms of excessive energy consumption.


There's a hidden subjective value judgment built into the word "excessive" that's doing a lot of the heavy lifting here. These "regulation" comments tend to have a high likelihood of boiling down "I want the government to stop things I don't like", where environmental concerns (crypto) or data collection (adtech) is a mere pretense grounded in incomplete information at best, emotion at worst.

Personally speaking I find it just as irritating of a pattern here that knee-jerk calls for "regulation" (i.e. bring in the coercive power of the state) or outright banning are so often floated as a/the solution to every problem. When legal coercion is suggested, it is entirely proper to bring up the existence of the dragons that lay down that road.


I want the government to look seriously at things that are using the energy footprint of a mid-sized country simply to spin up a new financial instrument. Particularly when there appear to be equivalent things that don't.

If cryptocurrencies didn't have the energy footprint, I would find them pretty uninteresting and/or ridiculous for various reasons, but ultimately it wouldn't bother me that people do what they do with them. When they start adding seriously to the global energy load in a time of climate crisis that makes them pretty offensive.


it's not simply a "new financial instrument", it's a whole ecossystem


I don't know whether you're referring to me or some of the other replies, but I am definitely against most forms of excessive energy consumption if they can be avoided.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: