Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>You don't need attendants on rail at all

Not true. You need people manning the cafeteria car, cleaning the bathrooms, checking tickets, etc.

>train should stop not less than once an hour

The Southwest Chief goes from San Bernardino, CA to Albuquerque, NM in 14 hours. It makes 8 stops along the way, inclusive of the endpoints. Your point here still largely stands, but these long haul trains most certainly do not stop at least once an hour.



> You need people manning the cafeteria car

Best practice is to not have them.

> cleaning the bathrooms

Do it at the end of the line when the train is stopped.

> The Southwest Chief

Amtrak is a bad example for anything. They are running tourist trains, and should follow the practices of cruise ships not modern railroads.


> Best practice is to not have them.

So no food options on a 14 hour train? The train's losing a lot of captured audiences there and people like to... eat. In that time the average US person eats at least three meals, you simply can't pack that much, especially for a family.

> Do it at the end of the line when the train is stopped.

Ever been to a music festival and looked at the toilets at the end of the day? Now imagine you're in a semi-airtight tube with that for 14 hours.

> Amtrak is a bad example for anything. They are running tourist trains, and should follow the practices of cruise ships not modern railroads

Have you ever taken one on the East Coast? They are not tourist trains, they're commuters and travelers.


Train trips of more than 5 hours run on cruise line principals and are not about getting to a destination. Any train for those trips is a tourist attraction and should pay for itself and all crew needed. Boston to NYC isn't 14 hours, and should not stick to steam train principles.

As for food, get off at any station and eat.

Yes bathrooms beed to be cleaned. However that is one person who cleans them between 2 stations and then nobody for the next station, and someone the station after. (This is an example, the real way to handle it might be different )




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: