Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>the huge elephant in the room is that it is insane that cities are more expensive when city dwellers consume less resources

50% of the world lives in cities yet they consume 70% of the worlds energy.



To enjoy modern standards of living, medium to high density urban arrangements are much less resource intensive than suburban sprawl, which the relevant comparison point.

The figure you quote, aggregated at the global level, entirely results from a comparison of city lifestyle with pre-industrial countryside lifestyles in developing countries. By contrast, living in the countryside or in suburbia in rich nations is much more environmentally damaging than in dense urban areas, which is what gp was referring to.


> The figure you quote, aggregated at the global level, entirely results from a comparison of city lifestyle with pre-industrial countryside lifestyles in developing countries.

Literally pre-industrial [1]. Last numbers I saw from the UN estimated 2 billion subsistence farmers as of 2015, all living without the benefit of modern agriculture except the occasional bag of fertilizer or engineered seeds. The future is very unevenly distributed.

[1] http://www.fao.org/3/i5251e/i5251e.pdf


Also keep in mind that turning nature into agriculture also has huge environmental costs not captured in energy usage.

If "developed cultured" is fixed by pricing the externalities, it would be absolutely better to pack people in cities, replace subsistence farming with sustainable industrial agriculture (no tilling, no aquifer depletion, etc.) and decrease the portion of land devoted to agriculture.


What are those numbers for American suburbs?

We're not comparing to the third world here, we're comparing across models of living in the developed world.


Is that because the 50% who don’t live in cities spend half their typical day in the nearest city?


I assume it's because people in cities are richer so they tend to consume more.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: