Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's not as bad on HN in my opinion, for a few reasons:

1. Comments cannot fall below -4 points

2. Downvoted comments only get greyed out, not hidden entirely

3. Most topics on HN are not political (though there are certainly exceptions)

4. The community here is (usually) a bit more mature than on other sites like Reddit



There's an inherent account age requirement on HN though, tied to the number of upvotes an account has


Surprisingly many topics are political [1], and an answer the very right-wing libertarian consensus here disagrees with will absolutely be voted all the way down.

[1] Often, the assertion "this topic is not or should not be political" is political. Because politics is how we organize society on a large scale and saying things should be exempt from that, guess what, is a political opinion.


Dunno, I'm pretty sure I've seen calls to break up or even nationalize Google and similar sentiments at the top quite a lot. That doesn't strike me as particularly right-wing?


The groupthink here isn't straight party-line, but it does have a lean.


That's moving the goalposts quite a bit from "...absolutely be voted all the way down."


Not really. It just means the topics people are touchy about don't follow the party line. They're still touchy and political about them.


I actually agree, I just think libertarian right wing is a mischaracterization, and I think it matters because the stereotype of the tech nerd is the atlas shrugged-toting libertarian, but HN doesn't really match that stereotype most of the time, I think.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: