Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

to be clear : the events of 9/11 were the impetus for war; not the motivation.

that trillion estimate, one of the lower ones by the way, is a cost figure without the associated profits and revenue. As horrible as it is and was, the 'military industrial complex', as a whole, profited incredibly -- this 'trickled down', a phrase I hate to use , all across the United States in the form of jobs from market players and call-for-bids across the nation to fill in niche topics (like airport security, for example) that were otherwise un-worked beforehand.

Another aside : the proof that airport security has changed anything for the better is scant at best, and corrupt at worst.

tl;dr : if you think any of the wars in the middle east were fought for the sake of 'American Safety', whatever that might be, then you're just not paying enough attention.



I mean, a trillion spent is a trillion spent: it'll trickle down regardless of how you spend it, the question is if you could have spent it some other way that would have given more jobs?


A trillion spent building factories, highways, public housing, schools, etc. may employ exactly as many people as a trillion spent building weapons, dropping bombs, and killing people.

What you end up with after spending that trillion is a bit different though.


> it'll trickle down regardless of how you spend it

That's an article of conservative dogma dating from the Reagan and Bush eras, and it's pretty-much discredited now. For most major capital expenditure programmes, the majority of the money trickling down stops trickling once it reaches shareholders and executives.


It was Bush - if it hadn’t been spent on Iraq it would have gone straight to tax cuts for the upper brackets.

We’re talking about the guy who managed to tank the worlds healthiest budget


I thought we were talking a miniature nuclear reactor…


Not if it is stashed away secretly avoiding tax and other contributions to society.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/frederickallen/2012/07/23/super...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: