Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> What lie exactly? Scotland had produced enough to power itself twice on Wind alone.

Doesn't say much for a variety of reasons:

- Even in Scotland, there's loads of days where there's "no wind" - on those days electricity has to be generated by gas or other means. So practically speaking as wind cannot be guaranteed it is impossible for Scotland to not generate carbon, via wind alone.

- As usual for breathless wind articles, completely fails to account for heating - which in Scotland makes up the bulk of domestic energy consumption and most homes are heated by gas combi boilers.

- Also as usual, neglects transport - another huge proportion of energy consumption

- Scotland is a best case scenario - it is very windy relative to other countries. It doesn't have a huge population. And as part of the UK national grid it makes sense to build a lot of wind capacity within Scotland. But then looking at statistics for Scotland in isolation doesn't really make sense - it should be done at a UK national grid level rather than trying to gerrymander things.

Wind is fine for reducing gas consumption when it happens to be windy. But if you really want to tackle climate change, you need to tackle having a need for gas consumption at all, and wind won't do it.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: