> Security reports from proper pentesters tend to include easy to reproduce steps and if you can't reproduce it yourself from that, you can ask them to expand, since it's in their interest for you to be able to understand them, since that's how they get paid.

Fair point, but it's also in their interest to overestimate the impact of the bug they found. And, even if the reports are well written, many reports that I've seen (mostly from new gray hats) were not actually exploitable, even with aggressive poc code.