> fair, Terraform was not an essential building block until somebody built it.
If terraform wasn’t available and wasn’t oss, its very likely that a competitor would have enjoyed the success and network benefits that were essential to its success and ubiquity.
Perhaps people don’t remember but not long ago there were many IaC tools to choose from, and it was a matter of taste as to which tool was adopted by a company. Chef, Ansible, Salt and a few others, all had pretty decent support as building blocks for infrastructure. Then terraform came along and was widely adopted, not just because it was better but also because it was oss (like its competitors).
Now that its won, Hashi feels comfortable to pull the rug and change the license.
Regardless of what the competitors think or do, this is a very unethical move from Hashicorp. I really want openTF and other clones to succeed and for Hashi to die. At the very least they should never again be trusted as good OSS stewards and any new product they come up with should be treated with scorn.
Which reminds me… when was the last time they built anything? Seems like all their effort is focused on commercialization. Which is…fine, they are a public company after all. They’re just not the same institution that they used to be. Just the name is same, and that is really fucked up.
> If terraform wasn’t available and wasn’t oss, its very likely that a competitor would have enjoyed the success and network benefits that were essential to its success and ubiquity.
Of course, but then would also have "enjoyed" the competition that didn't need to invest resources to build the thing.
> Now that its won, Hashi feels comfortable to pull the rug and change the license.
Not saying you're wrong. I'm saying the industry needs a better model for open source investment. The "tough shit, making money is your problem" view is not great, but the "open source until we're essential, then rug pull" is also terrible.
If terraform wasn’t available and wasn’t oss, its very likely that a competitor would have enjoyed the success and network benefits that were essential to its success and ubiquity.
Perhaps people don’t remember but not long ago there were many IaC tools to choose from, and it was a matter of taste as to which tool was adopted by a company. Chef, Ansible, Salt and a few others, all had pretty decent support as building blocks for infrastructure. Then terraform came along and was widely adopted, not just because it was better but also because it was oss (like its competitors).
Now that its won, Hashi feels comfortable to pull the rug and change the license.
Regardless of what the competitors think or do, this is a very unethical move from Hashicorp. I really want openTF and other clones to succeed and for Hashi to die. At the very least they should never again be trusted as good OSS stewards and any new product they come up with should be treated with scorn.
Which reminds me… when was the last time they built anything? Seems like all their effort is focused on commercialization. Which is…fine, they are a public company after all. They’re just not the same institution that they used to be. Just the name is same, and that is really fucked up.