Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

mmm actually no.

money laundering - the federal crime - relies, absolutely relies on their being an illicit origin. it cannot be charged independently and relies on discovering there was an illicit origin and moving to prosecute that.

think harder about it and successful money laundering is impossible to be convicted of as an illicit origin is never discovered and probable cause is never established to get the subpoenas.

seems that nobody ever imagined that the jury convicts someone on the money laundering charge and the judge acquits on the illicit origin charge amongst others. this does seem to require an appeal to rectify and everyone agrees he has a big chance of this getting dropped on appeal too, since its just dangling disconnected from its requirements.

the other things you’re talking about would be prosecuted under different laws.



> money laundering - the federal crime - relies, absolutely relies on their being an illicit origin. it cannot be charged independently and relies on discovering there was an illicit origin and moving to prosecute that.

There are money laundering laws that require it be illicit funds.

But there are also transaction reporting requirements - like generating a currency transaction report (CTR) - that don't require the funds to be illicit. It just requires that you attempt to circumvent them.

"The transaction is designed to evade any regulations promulgated under the Bank Secrecy Act"


yes “structuring” is illegal. its not a “money laundering law”, perhaps a capital control. its unproductive to play into the idea that all movement of money is laundering and it isnt moving a discussion forward when the language is conflating everything.

I can see the categorization of "AML" - anti-money laundering law. I think then that the context hasn't been made clear, when we are discussing the actual criminal charge of money laundering, versus the criminal charge of structuring or avoiding a transaction reporting threshold.


Meh... it's the media. I wouldn't expect any precision in their reporting.

"Man guilty of violating laws in place to prevent money laundering" becomes "Man guilty of money laundering".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: