Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You've obviously never had the government show up at your door saying these words.


I've had lots of very helpful interactions with government employees throughout my life. As a matter of fact, there have clearly been many more unambiguously positive experiences than negative ones. Of course, we are both just playing the anecdote game here, but why should that stop anyone from asserting opinion as fact?


I have also had "helpful interactions" with the government.

However, I have also had people from the government show up at my door, unannounced, and these were indeed some of the most terrifying experiences of my life.

Talk to other victims of state violence under communism, fascism, imperialism or even modern western democracies and it's quite obvious that this fear is justified.

One way to frame it: "government showing up at your door" has murdered millions (billions?) of people. This is a historical fact. Not opinion. Not anecdote.


You make a lot of qualifications to your original statement in this follow up! You'd be a lot more successful getting your point across if you wrote clearly to begin with, instead of starting with obviously untrue hyperbole. Another way to frame it is that "government showing up at your door" very frequently doesn't end up with billions dead.


What qualifications?

"Government showing up at your door" has killed at least millions of people. When it shows up at your door, you should be afraid because of this historical fact.

Are you denying governments have killed millions of people?

> Another way to frame it is that "government showing up at your door" very frequently doesn't end up with billions dead.

It will very frequently turn out to be very bad news for you and/or your family if the government shows up at your door, especially if unannounced, especially if they need to tell you they're here to help. A firefighter will never have to explain to you "I'm here to help"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: