Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Poll: Allow override of noprocrast?
18 points by pg on Feb 3, 2009 | hide | past | favorite | 15 comments
I recently got rid of the override option on noprocrast. Should I put it back?
no, get rid of override
69 points
yes, keep override
34 points
what is noprocrast?
34 points
either way is fine
32 points


Could you get rid of the override when following links from the homepage but allow it when direct-linking into a post?

I wouldn't care about the override, except that I often have to refer back to previous topics for some technical advice, or end up coming across news.YC from a Google search. It's really frustrating to hit the noprocrast timeout in those cases, particularly since I'm usually doing work at the time.


You can get around procrast in this case by deleting your HN cookie. The next time you visit you would have to login again.


You should lose karma if you override it


You do, in a way. Only you lose real-life karma through diminished possibility for success :)

The procrast thing always seemed insanely odd to me. It's trivial to override and it seems like a diet plan akin to writing "don't eat me" on all the junk food in your house.

Read HN or do not. There is noprocrast.


The procrast thing always seemed insanely odd to me.

Agreed. I imagine an ad, seen by a character in a Philip K. Dick novel:

"Noprocrast! The best way for current you to impose your will on future you, guaranteed! For the disciplinarian in all of us, at last, a ready and willing subject!"


For those of us that need it, it makes all kinds of sense. Figuring out better ways to control future me is an ongoing project of mine.

A couple weeks ago I gave my buddy $20, if I get my app out for sale by the end of the month I get it back, if not he spends it.


I like the feature, and the override.

Sometimes I pull up the site and it gently reminds me that I've spent a lot of time reading it lately.

Other times it's the weekend or I've left my window open for a while (is this how it works?) and I'd like to get back to the site. I've disabled the feature for now since there's no override.


I just fucked myself with this. Now I have to wait 5 more hours and can't override it. I learned what noprocrast was the hard way.


and please get rid of retry button too, doesn't refreshing the page serve the same purpose?


I can't believe anyone would actually use such a thing.

Discipline, people, discipline.


The best way to acquire or extinguish a habit is with consistent, salient feedback. noprocrast is a tool that helps to remind and reinforce the user of their desire to not procrastinate. i think adding a captcha to the noprocrast page would make it more useful as it would require more thought than a simple click-through, which is easily habituated as well.


maybe more like google's gmail googles, where you have to solve 5 2-digit math problems in under 60 seconds. but this time, make them really freaking hard.

But, no, I'd just as soon not have override at all.


Yes. I want noprocrast on while I'm in lab or doing homework, but I want to be able to override when I'm done.


just get leechblock for ff3...


the downside of that is that web developers tend to have several browsers at their fingertips.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: