Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You would like to limit immigration. What would companies like google like look after that? Would you advocate sending the head of youtube back to Iran? What about much of Detroit or New York?

You're conflating some poverty-stricken residents of impoverished parts of the world riled up by political rhetoric with a credible enemy (like a cold war style superpower).

You're arguments make as much sense as labeling all white people everywhere as Nazis because Hitler was a white guy.

Go to Liberia or the Congo or India. You'll see that people aren't civilized, they will eat each other if out of ritual. That was the case everywhere over a 100 years ago. You miss that it's not some kind of inherent badness, they are simply living in a different time, like 1800s europe for example. If children commit crimes they are not convicted in the same manner as adults, that's the correct analogy to take.

As civilized people and members of the global species that is humanity, it's a responsibility to take care of the weak. The problems you've outlined are (global) law enforcement problems. And they are disappearing, as time passes everyone on earth will become modern. Watch some Steven Pinker and see how today is the most peaceful time in human history.

Watch Carl Sagan's blue dot and realize it's not Us vs Them. That's the thinking of pre-space age man.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WibmcsEGLKo (Charlie Chaplin)



> You would like to limit immigration. What would companies like google like look after that? Would you advocate sending the head of youtube back to Iran? What about much of Detroit or New York?

I'm not talking about educated people, and like I said above, this issue is not particularly applicable to America, it's more relevant to Europe. In Europe, there is a serious issue with Muslim immigrants not integrating into mainstream society, and this is because many European nations accepted large numbers of Muslim immigrants in an indiscriminate fashion.


You've completely missed the point. There are not Us vs Them. There are simply people. If you would like to label people as uneducated or muslims or whatever else, then you have engaged in that fallacy that pre-space age humankind engaged. You should really watch that link I gave as well as the Pale Blue Dot and let it really sink in.


Holy cow, I would not have guessed that this thread would be where you least trollish post of the week would be.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: