Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I want people to be REAL careful about "Israel obviously committed a genocide"

All those people brutally murdered on October 7 don't just disappear. Whatever you think about Israel's response it's kind of amazing the main focus is on the "big bad" of Israel

There were pro-Pally protests on October 8! If not October 7. Before the bodies were cool, so to speak

If you were pro-Palestine it is absolutely your moral duty to not just be silent. There is absolutely no ambiguity here. The Islamic Republic is slaughtering Iranians

Edit: And I don't give a damn if this is "construed as hostile", if you downvote me for this (Already one in the last minute) you do not deserve the 500 karma you have to be able to downvote me. I, in fact, suggest that you delete your account



Whether or not Israel was provoked has nothing to do with whether or not Israel is committing genocide. How many eyes need to be claimed to repay those that were lost? They have gone far beyond the 1:1 ratio everyone is familiar with from the ancient saying.


And you get your numbers from what? The Hamas controlled Ministry of Health?


No matter who you get the numbers from, Israel has killed far more than 1200 Palestinians.


Then Hamas was VERY stupid for attacking on Oct 7 2023


There’s no magic right to kill n people for n deaths. If 1 person killed a 1000 people, that doesn’t give you the right to kill 1000 people.

If an army of 100,000 attempts to kill as many people as they can but have only managed 1000 so far, you can kill as many as many of them as you need until they stop trying to kill you.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: