Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I would expect further H1B crackdowns coming. The $100k fee was just the start.


I disagree, I think the $100k fee was a deliberate move to make sure the yearly allocation is only available to large companies like Oracle and out of reach of smaller startups.

Despite the rhetoric the administration is very friendly to big business and will absolutely help them hire cheaply. Larry Ellison especially.


Absolutely not. The current administration had a chance to do something really radical and they just completely fumbled it. They won't reopen this file.


Every administration until this one has had a chance to do something about h1b and didn't do jack. At least this administration is doing SOMETHING.


They barely did anything. They could have done something great. They could have ended the program all together, they could have put a serious cap on it, they could have made the $100k fee a yearly fee, etc

But no, they did virtually nothing. I would even be surprised if more than 100 companies paid the one time $100k fee at this point with all the loopholes that were included.


I would absolutely not expect this, especially as long as Oracle and all the other technofeudalists are properly paying their taxes to the count and king.


By taxes, do you mean buying Trump's crypto?


The government is not the friend you think it is.

All the new regulations (carefully presented as crackdown) make it easier for large companies to hire immigrants in a more reliable way. All carefully choreographed by big tech.

The chances of a specific company being able to sponsor a specific employee through this year's lottery went by significantly (3-4x) compared to the last several years.


USCIS says they competed the 2027 quota. Is there any evidence all enrolled paid $100k this year ?


I would assume many were change-of-status from F-1 / OPT etc.


The giant gaping loophole they left in place. Renewals and COS (change of status) does not incur the $100k fee.


Then the H-1B wouldn’t make sense. Many holders would have to transfer from one company to another, and if there is a $100,000 requirement, it would just lead to exploitation.

The better solution is just stop H1B lottery from next year.


They should remove the lottery and make it a bidding war. Highest bidder gets the H-1B visas.

Realistically, the H-1B visa program should be terminated all together.


Gosh I hope this is true!


Good. Call your reps and ask for more action.


Isn’t Larry friends with the administration?


Sadly I think you're wrong on this one. Trump's donors benefit from H1B cheap labor. Musk, Elison, etc contributed large sums to Trump's campaign. Just look at Musk's "fuck your own face" tweets from Dec 2024 and you'll see how the people with power feel about this issue. As usual the middle class is being squeezed by the oligarchy.

The 100k fee basically does nothing to curb H1B cheap labor. It's a one-time fee, and when you realize that H1B's can't easily leave their job, it's a fee that easily pays for itself. H1B's are paid less for the same job (just google "are H1B's paid less"), and since they can't easily leave, the reduced turnover saves them money as well. If you think that an employee is likely to stay for 4 years, that's only 25k per year and the fact that they are paid about 15%-20% less than an American, the equation still easily comes out in favor of importing the cheap labor.

It was a move crafted to look like it was cracking down on abuse, but not actually cause any real pain to the companies abusing the system. Hence why all these mega corps are still filing for H1B's even while laying off their American citizen workers.


I thought the $100k h1b fee is annual


It was announced as such, but the administration quietly issued an update the day after it was announced “clarifying” that it was actually a one-time fee.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: