Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Full responsibility. Let's break that down.

Full responsibility, on the surface, means that Manning is taking full responsibility under the law, and is not shying away from the legal consequences of his actions. He knows that according to the laws and the power structure, he's accountable for his actions which threaten said laws and power structure. Those self-interested parties will react in the appropriate way to defend the status quo.

Full responsibility to history means something else entirely.

Full responsibility to history means that Manning doesn't shy away from the responsibility he has in challenging a corrupt power structure, and fighting for the rule of law. He's accepting responsibility for standing up for truth, in spite of the legal consequences. He's accepting full responsibility for being part of something bigger than himself.

Salutes



> the responsibility he has in challenging a corrupt power structure

What's the corrupt power structure and how did he challenge it?


... you can't be serious. What exact part of that sentence are you taking issue with? The corrupt-ness of the US military and/or government, or the fact that releasing this information was a challenging act?


Bradley Manning is probably going to spend the rest of his life in prison. He's only 25! Holy shit that's a long time.

He intentionally and indiscriminately released thousands of classified documents in direct violation of his duties.

What specific instances of corruption did he uncover that justify what he did?

Look, he was clearly unhappy. From what I've read it sounds like he was lonely, confused, and unstable. But he was given significant responsibilities and he violated that trust in a _very_ serious and criminal way.

If he was unhappy there are many, many other things he could have done than release those files.

What I see is this thread is just a bunch of platitudes. Yeah! he stuck it to the man! But what did he actually achieve? All I see is a fucked up young man making a _huge_ mistake.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: