Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I can't speak of his personal behavior. I've never been in a room with him nor read any accounts of that. However, dismissing his expertise as simple "flattery" without really breaking it down is dishonest. Kissinger has a track record of being quite successful. I know some countries came out worse because of him but it doesn't diminish his insights.


>dismissing his expertise as simple "flattery"

>Kissinger has a track record of being quite successful

Luttwak's view is precisely that Kissinger engages in flattery to expand his own personal influence.


I haven't read Luttwak's book but he seems like a smart guy. I hope in the book he does more than just call it "flattery" and talk about Kissinger's wife, which is what the linked article does. My guess is that Luttwak breaks down Kissinger's ideas. My problem isn't with Luttwak or his book. I haven't read it to be able to judge. I just don't like this article and I think it doesn't do a good job of advancing Luttwak's idea. Why would he even deviate into personal things about Kissinger like his wife?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: