Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Joe is right, you did contradict yourself. You originally said that tenure allows teachers to violate stupid school board decisions and to teach evolution anyway. Here, you said that tenure does not allow teachers to not teach evolution if the school board mandates it.

Which is it? Can the school board fire teachers for not following the curriculum? If so, then school boards can stop teachers from teaching evolution. If not, then teachers can choose to teach Creationism. Either way, tenure doesn't matter.



> How much do you want to bet violating such a ban would lead to immediate dismissal without tenure protections?

Another way to phrase that would be: Teachers can violate such a ban temporarily.

It isn't blanket immunity and that isn't what I said.


So teachers can only teach evolution temporarily until the school board fires them and implements Creationism?


Assuming the Church/State separation vanishes, yes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: