Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I agree. I think, however, we can forgive chton for not parsing out the best word for "kind of badness" prior to our semantic discussion. (If we are to be charitable in understanding his/her comment, then we should assume "kind of badness" was the intent.)

For the record, I greatly prefer confusing to misleading. I would rather people have an incomplete understanding than an incorrect one.



> For the record, I greatly prefer confusing to misleading.

On this much, we agree -- in general at least.

OTOH, often, there are good reasons for prefering particular misleading descriptions over more confusing but less misleading ones (pedagogically, for instance, sequences of progressively-less-misleading explanations are often used, each of which is designed to limit how confusing it is to the target audience, to develop progressively better understanding.)


Agreed again. I often quote my intro to computer engineering professor who said, "Education is a series of small lies" when told us some circuits have ternary logic, not just binary. But I feel that this headline is not in that group.


I think that's true most of the time, but in this particular case, it probably isn't doing anyone much good (aside from the beneficiaries of that clickbait admoney)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: