Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Uhm no, absolutely not. The basic operational principle remained the same, but absolutely everything has been changed many times over. Trillions of dollars were invested to make it happen.

The only constant is probably that it is still made on a silicon wafer. But even this wafer changed a lot, and I am not talking about its size.

Would you also compare a horse carriage to a Tesla?



Would you also compare a horse carriage to a Tesla?

I think it would be closer to a comparison between a car engine in the 1900s and one today. Lots of differences, but the basic principles remain the same and if you were to give someone from one time period a part from the other, they'd easily be able to see what it was.


No. Chemicals are different, structures are different, design is different (cmos), etching equipment is different. I am at a loss to name a recognizable thing.


The wafer is a slab of polysilicon, and has been that way for a long time. Most of those trillions you mention were invested to make the lithography smaller, which is how you get more transistors into the same die.

Edit: silicon, not poly silicon. Not sure why I said poly there...


No, simply no.

ICs are made of monocrystalline silicon, not polysilicon. There have been massive efforts to understand how to make it cleaner (internal gettering) and how to get wafer mechanics under control (Nitrogen doping). That does not even touch the changes in production technology to go from 10 mm Wafers to 300 mm Wafers. (You just make them larger, right...)

A lot of new concepts and materials have been introduced to ICs during the last decades. Especially since the 130 nm ground rule, lithography has not been the main limiter. Examples: Copper, Tungsten, Diffusion barriers, Silicide, Strained Silicon, High-k, metal gates, finfet, 3d integration etc...


10 mm wafers? Were they ever that small? I've never heard of less than 1 inch...


The transistors used today are very different from the transistors used back then, not just in size but also in structure and materials. The silicon die is pretty much the only part of the system that has stayed the same -- everything else has been changed, one part at a time.


You probably said "polysilicon" because this chip has some polysilicon deposited on top.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: