Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Firefox's Plan to Kick the Login's Butt (readwriteweb.com)
37 points by alexandros on Nov 25, 2009 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


Does anyone else get annoyed when an article's content is primarily from another article and that article doesn't even get a link?

Or in this case is embedded in one word in a paragraph.


So long as they release code to be able to implement this on your own projects and not just the big names it might catch on to have browsers do more login management like the post talked about.


It would be nice to have an integrated OpenID interface. The way it is now, OpenID is just too complicated for the average user.


Agreed. I've logged into sites using OpenID, and while I can step through the process, I don't quite understand what's going on behind the scenes, except that it let's me log in to a site in a very obtuse fashion.


Google Apps for Domains

+ myopenid.com

+ Weave / (this)

+ Boku / Zong

== Awesome total user experience.


All it really needed was an http auth logout button years ago. Http auth has built in MD5 hashing too so sniffing is harder (though some auto salting would help).


Well, the established fashion is a login form right in the page. I think there are many users who are confused by the standard HTTP auth box (those dialogs being ugly doesn't help, and the Firefox one is the worst-looking of the bunch).


It wouldn't be hard to extend HTML in order to support HTTP-auth (digest auth) via normal forms. The logout-button feature would be a natural addition as well. Think along the lines of a javascript call or a magic form-target.

This is just one of the many failures of the W3C.

Authentication is at the core of every webapp, browsers already support a strong mechanism - but with interface issues so severe that everybody prefers to invent their own.

The fix outlined above could be specified in a week and implemented in another. In W3C terms that translates to: 1-2 decades.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: